It obviously appeals to a lot of YA females. It appeals to a lot of Adult females. Where do we draw the line, though, in what is appropriate for the YA audience? I personally think that this book got classified as YA because it had little language and no blatant immorality.
Is it the author's responsibility to classify the book or the publishing industry's? Is it Stephenie Meyer's decision or her agent's or her publisher's? or should we open it up to the national movie rating system's? If I were rating the book like a movie, I would give it a PG-13 rating. Does that mean then that it is appropriate for 13 year olds? I'm just asking. I'd love to hear what you all are thinking.